The allure of a compact, city-fringe condominium as a stepping stone onto Singapore's private property ladder is losing its shine. What was once seen as an affordable entry point for singles and a straightforward investment for rental yield is now revealing its downside: a growing difficulty in resale. Owners of one-bedroom and studio apartments are discovering that a lower purchase price can come at the cost of sluggish price growth and a more challenging exit strategy, a trend substantiated by market data showing these smaller units consistently underperform their larger counterparts in both capital appreciation and profitability.
While the overall private residential property price index continues its ascent, climbing 1.0% in the second quarter of 2025, a closer look reveals a significant performance gap based on unit size. Between 2019 and 2024, studio and one-bedroom condos saw an average annual price increase of just 3%. In stark contrast, two- to five-bedroom units enjoyed much healthier growth, ranging from 5% to 8% annually. This disparity directly impacts an owner's return on investment, making the dream of a quick, profitable sale an elusive reality for many.
The Profitability Gap and a Shrinking Buyer Pool
The challenge of selling smaller condominium units extends beyond slower price growth; it directly hits the owner's bottom line. Data reveals a clear profitability hierarchy: about 89% of one-bedder and studio resales turn a profit. While this figure may seem high in isolation, it pales in comparison to the success rates of larger units. For two-bedroom apartments, the profitability rate jumps to 93%, climbing further to 95% for three and four-bedroom units, and peaking at an impressive 99% for five-bedders.
The fundamental reason for this gap lies in the target demographic. Smaller units cater to a very specific and narrow segment of the market—predominantly singles or young couples without children. As these individuals' lives evolve and their spatial needs grow, the compact layouts of studio and one-bedroom apartments quickly become restrictive. This limitation curtails the pool of potential resale buyers, as many are willing to stretch their budgets for a two-bedroom unit that offers greater long-term flexibility and space.
This dynamic creates a resale market where the demand is simply not as robust. While the lower initial cost keeps these units attractive to first-time buyers and some investors, the exit strategy is complicated by a limited number of subsequent buyers who fit the same narrow profile.
Crowded Market and the New Launch Squeeze
Owners of older one-bedroom units face a formidable competitor: the modern, hyper-efficient layouts of new launches. Developers, aiming to keep quantum prices manageable amidst rising costs, have mastered the art of fitting more rooms into smaller footprints. It is now common to see new projects offering three-bedroom units within an 800 to 900 sq ft space, a size that once might have accommodated a generous one-bedroom apartment.
This shift drastically alters the value proposition, especially for investor-buyers who dominate the small-unit segment. An investor's primary concern is often rental yield and eventual capital gain, and new developments with more rooms, modern facilities, and a fresh lease are often a more attractive proposition. The result is a crowded resale market where older, less efficient one-bedroom units struggle to stand out and command a premium.
The sheer volume of small units listed for resale underscores this challenge. As of early September 2025, thousands of one-bedroom condos built between 2010 and 2025 were listed for sale on major property portals. This significant supply reflects not just healthy investor activity over the past decade, but also the current difficulties many owners face in offloading their properties in a competitive landscape.
The Challenge of Finding the Next Investor
A critical flaw in the investment thesis for many small condo units is the assumption that another investor will be waiting to buy it on the resale market. While these properties are often snapped up by investors during a new launch, attracted by marketing hype and early-bird pricing, the pool of investors willing to purchase a secondhand small unit is significantly smaller. Resale properties lack the pristine condition, developer-led financing packages, and the psychological allure of being the "first owner."
This creates a broken link in the investment chain. The initial buyer, looking for an exit, finds that the very demographic they belonged to is now focused on the next new project launch, not the resale market. Consequently, sellers are forced to pivot their strategy and compete for the limited pool of owner-occupiers, primarily singles. This places their compact, aging unit in direct competition with slightly larger, more practical two-bedroom apartments, often forcing them to temper price expectations just to close a deal.
The Illusion of Effortless Rental Yields
For years, the primary argument for investing in shoebox units was their attractive rental yield, driven by a lower purchase price. However, this appeal is increasingly becoming a mirage. The substantial supply of small rental units creates fierce competition, putting downward pressure on rental rates and giving tenants significant bargaining power. Landlords often face longer vacancy periods between leases, and even a single month without a tenant can severely impact the year's overall return.
Furthermore, investors often focus on the gross rental yield while underestimating the numerous costs that erode the final net profit. Monthly maintenance fees, which do not scale down linearly with unit size, can take a proportionally larger bite out of the rental income from a small apartment. Coupled with property taxes, mortgage interest, and occasional agent fees for tenant sourcing, the actual cash flow can be disappointingly slim, sometimes failing to cover the monthly expenses and forcing owners to top up cash, turning the investment into a liability.
Rethinking the "Affordable" Investment
The experience of many small condo owners serves as a cautionary tale against viewing these properties as a guaranteed path to wealth accumulation. While the initial entry price is comparatively affordable, the total cost of ownership—including mortgage payments, maintenance fees, and property taxes—can quickly erode potential gains, especially if the unit struggles to secure consistent tenancy at a favorable rate. The narrative of a French investor who took three years to sell her Marina Bay Residences unit for a negligible profit after a decade of ownership is a stark reminder of this risk.
For prospective buyers, the focus must shift from merely the entry price to a more holistic consideration of the exit strategy. The data strongly suggests that while the upfront cost is higher, larger units offer a more reliable trajectory for capital appreciation and a broader, more liquid resale market. The willingness of buyers to pay a premium for space and flexibility is a trend that has solidified in the post-pandemic era.
Looking ahead, while declining household sizes may provide a steady baseline demand for smaller units, the significant supply and intense competition from newer, more efficient layouts will likely continue to suppress their price growth relative to larger apartments. Aspiring homeowners and investors must therefore weigh the immediate affordability of a one-bedroom condo against the long-term financial reality: a potentially longer holding period, lower profitability, and a decidedly more challenging sales process.

Shaun
Founder
With over a decade of expertise spanning investment advisory, investment banking analysis, oil trading, and financial advisory roles, RealisedGains is committed to empowering retail investors to achieve lasting financial well-being. By delivering meticulously curated investment insights and educational programs, RealisedGains equips individuals with the knowledge and tools to make sophisticated, informed financial decisions.
The Easiest Way Ever To Pass Your Financial Licensing Exam With Minimum Time And Money
Your career deserves the best tool
Disclaimer: Practice materials are 100% original by RealisedGains — unaffiliated with IBF, SCI, or MAS, for educational use only.
With over a decade of expertise spanning investment advisory, investment banking analysis, oil trading, and financial advisory roles, RealisedGains is committed to empowering retail investors to achieve lasting financial well-being. By delivering meticulously curated investment insights and educational programs, RealisedGains equips individuals with the knowledge and tools to make sophisticated, informed financial decisions.
© 2025 RealisedGains | All Rights Reserved | www.realisedgains.com
The go to platform that keeps you informed on the financial markets. Best of all, it's free.
The go to platform that keeps you informed on the financial markets. Best of all, it's free.
About
Products
Tools
Market News
Personal Finance
Socials
© 2025 RealisedGains | All Rights Reserved | www.realisedgains.com